Alan Cooper
2/11/2012 3:57:00 AM
Steve Emerson <emersn@n-n-nospamsonic.net> wrote in
news:emersn-BC6E2B.15190510022012@nnrp-virt.nntp.sonic.net:
> In article <jh0pi601ua5@drn.newsguy.com>,
> Paul Goldstein <pgoldste@newsguy.com> wrote:
>
>> In article
>> <d96c8405-755a-49d4-89c3-54c6c3e92f4c@vd8g2000pbc.googlegroups.c
>> om>, Oscar says...
>> The Guarneris' RCA Mozart is excellent - this is an attractive
>> box.
>
> I agree on their quartets. But here's the thing. The set
> contains:
>
> --The six quartets dedicated to Haydn (just coming out of a
> budget
> release of their own); and
> --The string quintets.
>
> The Prussian quartets that they did (just two? or all three?)
> have never appeared on CD, to my knowledge, and aren't included
> here. Those are at least on a par with their quartets dedicated
> to Haydn.
All three, reissued on ArkivCD. The K589/590 coupling was one of their two
debut LPs (the other coupled Smetana #1 w/Dvorak op. 105), and the Gramophone
reviewer's characterization ("distinguished Mozart playng indeed") is no
exaggeration. K575 was recorded about five years later, and I was never as
enamored of it as of the other two works, although it's more than listenable.
AC